Affiliate disclosure: PestPro Index is reader-supported. When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. This helps us keep the site running and free for everyone. As an Amazon Associate, PestPro Index earns from qualifying purchases.
This page compares four cockroach sprays and one gel bait. The Pest Expert kit is the overall pick if the problem has spread beyond one room, and the NOPE! pack gives you ten litres when there is a lot of ground to cover. If you want a bait, the Pest Expert Formula IC gel comes in six syringes with an applicator.
The Five Products Compared
Every column below is what the Amazon listing itself states. Where a listing does not state something, the cell says so rather than guessing.
| Product | Active substance and size, as listed | Award |
|---|---|---|
| Pest Expert Cockroach Killer Kit (Advanced) | Spray; cypermethrin with pyriproxyfen | Best Overall |
| NOPE! CP Cockroach Killer Spray | Cypermethrin; 5L x 2 as listed | Best Alternative |
| Rentokil Insectrol 250ml | Permethrin + D-allethrin | Best Spray |
| Zero In Ant & Cockroach Killer 1.5L | Cypermethrin + benzalkonium chloride | Best Budget |
| Pest Expert Formula IC Gel 6 x 10g | Imidacloprid; 6 x 10g | Best Gel Bait |
Best Overall — Pest Expert Cockroach Killer Kit (Advanced)
Product
Pest Expert Cockroach Killer Kit (Advanced)
Best Overall
- Item form listed as Spray; target species listed as Cockroach
- Listed as covering 3-4 rooms
- The maker claims a residue that continues to protect for up to 12 weeks
- Listed as low-odour and non-staining
- Supplied with a step-by-step advice sheet
As an Amazon Associate, PestPro Index earns from qualifying purchases.
For when the problem has spread beyond one room. The kit is listed as covering 3 to 4 rooms and comes with a step-by-step advice sheet, and its description names cypermethrin and pyriproxyfen. The maker claims a residue that goes on protecting for up to 12 weeks, and the listing describes it as low-odour and non-staining.
Pros:
- Listed as covering 3 to 4 rooms
- Step-by-step advice sheet included
- Up to 12 weeks of residue, the maker claims
- Low-odour and non-staining, as listed
Best Alternative — NOPE! CP Cockroach Killer Spray 5L (Pack of 2)
Spray
NOPE! CP Cockroach Killer Spray 5L (Pack of 2)
Best Alternative
- Listed as 5 litres, pack of two — 10 litres in total
- Active substance stated on the listing: cypermethrin
- Listed as an odourless trigger spray for spot treatments
- Listed as having disinfectant properties
- Target species listed as Cockroach
As an Amazon Associate, PestPro Index earns from qualifying purchases.
Choose this if you have a lot of ground to cover. You get two 5 litre packs, ten litres in all, of an odourless trigger spray for spot treatments, with cypermethrin named on the listing. The maker also claims disinfectant properties.
Pros:
- 10 litres in two 5 litre packs
- Cypermethrin named on the listing
- Odourless trigger spray for spot treatments
- Disinfectant properties, the maker claims
Best Spray — Rentokil Insectrol Insect Killer Spray 250ml
Spray
Rentokil Insectrol Insect Killer Spray 250ml
Best Spray
- Active substances stated on the listing: permethrin and D-allethrin
- 250ml aerosol, listed at 3.53 ounces
- Listed as intended for indoor use
- Listed for fleas, ants, cockroaches, earwigs and bed bugs
- Target species listed as Insects
As an Amazon Associate, PestPro Index earns from qualifying purchases.
For a small indoor job, this is a 250ml can. The listing names permethrin and D-allethrin and says it is intended for indoor use. It lists fleas, ants, cockroaches, earwigs and bed bugs among its targets, so one can covers more than one pest.
Pros:
- 250ml aerosol
- Permethrin and D-allethrin named on the listing
- Listed for cockroaches, ants, fleas, earwigs and bed bugs
- Intended for indoor use, as listed
Best Budget — Zero In Ant & Cockroach Killer 1.5L Ready-to-Use
Product
Zero In Ant & Cockroach Killer 1.5L Ready-to-Use
Best Budget
- Active substances stated on the listing: cypermethrin and benzalkonium chloride
- 1.5L pressurised pump spray with an adjustable nozzle
- Listed for fan spray or crack-and-crevice treatment
- Listed for indoor and outdoor use
- Target species listed as Insects
As an Amazon Associate, PestPro Index earns from qualifying purchases.
Choose this if you need to treat outside as well as in. It is a 1.5 litre pressurised pump spray with an adjustable nozzle for either a fan spray or crack-and-crevice treatment, and the listing names cypermethrin and benzalkonium chloride.
Pros:
- 1.5L pressurised pump spray
- Adjustable nozzle for fan spray or crack and crevice
- Listed for indoor and outdoor use
- Cypermethrin and benzalkonium chloride named
Best Gel Bait — Pest Expert Formula IC Cockroach Killer Gel 6 x 10g
Gel bait
Pest Expert Formula IC Cockroach Killer Gel 6 x 10g
Best Gel Bait
- Six 10g syringes of gel, as listed
- Active listed as imidacloprid
- Supplied with a ready-to-use syringe applicator, as listed
- Target species listed as Cockroach
- The listing's detail table shows a different ASIN (B07ZZCZRXG) from the page fetched — a variant listing
As an Amazon Associate, PestPro Index earns from qualifying purchases.
If you want a bait, this is the one gel on the page, and baiting is the first treatment option UF/IFAS names. You get six 10g syringes with a ready-to-use applicator, imidacloprid is named as the active, and the target species is listed as cockroach.
Pros:
- Six 10g syringes of gel
- Imidacloprid named as the active
- Ready-to-use syringe applicator, as listed
- Target species listed as cockroach
Start with your situation
- You came here for gel bait. There is one on this page. The other four cards are contact sprays — a spray kit, a 5-litre trigger spray sold in a pack of two, a 250ml aerosol and a 1.5-litre pump spray — and the published guidance rates baiting above spraying — what this page actually cards.
- You want to know what a householder can buy. What a householder can buy.
- You have sprayed already and they came back. A surface spray does not reach a harbourage — where a spray does not help.
- You want to know what is in it. All four name an active substance, and they are not the same — the comparison table states which.
Warning
Cockroaches in a home are usually a sign the problem is bigger than a spray can reach. If you are seeing them in daylight, or in more than one room, that is the point to get a professional in rather than treating again.
What This Page Actually Cards
Four contact sprays and one gel. Read from their own listings: a treatment kit whose item form is Spray, a five-litre trigger spray sold in a pack of two, a 250ml aerosol, a 1.5-litre pump spray, and six 10g syringes of imidacloprid gel. No bait station. The Pest Expert kit’s description names pyriproxyfen, which its own listing calls an insect growth regulator.
The University of Florida’s extension guidance on assessment-based management of German cockroaches puts it the other way round: “Baiting, insect growth regulators (IGRs), and vacuums with high-efficiency particulate air filters—(HEPA) are the most effective treatment options for cockroach suppression.” (UF/IFAS). That is a US extension service writing about the German cockroach, which is the species that infests UK kitchens too; the guidance is about the animal, not the country.
What a Householder Can Buy
The products on this page are amateur-authorised insecticides sold over the counter. Read the label on the one you buy and use it only as the label says — that is a condition of sale, not a suggestion, and it is the same principle that governs rodenticides.
All four spray listings name their active substance: cypermethrin on one, permethrin with D-allethrin on another, cypermethrin with benzalkonium chloride on the third, and cypermethrin with pyriproxyfen on the Pest Expert kit. Only the Rentokil aerosol carries it as a detail field; the other three state it in the description, which is the part of a listing it is easiest to skip.
Where a Spray Does Not Help
A surface spray treats surfaces. Cockroaches spend most of their time in harbourage — behind and under appliances, in voids, in the warm space at the back of a fitted kitchen. A spray reaches what it lands on.
Sanitation is doing more work than any product here. UF/IFAS treats monitoring and sanitation as the first level of a management strategy, before any insecticide, and recommends sticky traps to find out what is actually happening: “Use sticky traps. They are your "eyes" in the property and are working for you 24/7.” (UF/IFAS).
Repeat spraying is a warning sign, not a plan. If a second treatment has not held, the problem is where the insects are living, not how much you sprayed.
What Decides the Choice
1. Which active substance the listing names
All four name one and they are not the same. It is the only property on this page you can check before buying, and it is what a label condition attaches to.
2. Indoor only, or indoor and out
The Rentokil aerosol is listed as intended for indoor use. The Zero In spray is listed for indoors and out. That decides where each can go.
3. How much you are actually buying
Pack sizes here range from a 250ml aerosol to ten litres. One card names a size its own listing contradicts, which the table records.
If a Spray Is Not the Answer
Bait, not spray, is what the guidance rates first. One gel bait is carded above; the listing it is read from names its active and its target species and nothing about where to place it, which is a label matter.
Monitor before you treat again. Sticky traps tell you where they are, which is the question a second spray does not answer.
Get a professional in for anything established. Cockroach infestations in shared or multi-room buildings are rarely solved from a shelf — compare providers below.
Using Them
- Read the label on the pack that arrives. The listing names the substance; only the label carries the conditions of use.
- Treat cracks and crevices, not open surfaces. That is where the insects are, and two of these listings offer a crack-and-crevice setting for exactly that.
- Keep the indoor-only product indoors. The Rentokil aerosol is listed for indoor use.
- Clean first and keep cleaning. Food debris and warmth are what hold an infestation in place.
- Put monitors down and read them. If they keep filling, stop spraying and call someone.
Cockroaches in more than one room?
An established cockroach infestation is rarely solved from a shelf. Compare pest control providers near you — no fees, no commissions.