Affiliate disclosure: PestPro Index is reader-supported. When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. This helps us keep the site running and free for everyone. As an Amazon Associate, PestPro Index earns from qualifying purchases.
This page compares four zipped encasements that cover the whole mattress. The SafeRest carries the strongest bed bug claim, which the maker says is lab tested and certified. The Utopia goes in the washing machine and tumble dryer, and the SureGuard has a cotton terry surface the maker calls noiseless. All four give US sizes, so measure your mattress before you order.
The Four Compared
Every column below is what the Amazon listing itself states, with each claim attributed to the maker who makes it. Where a listing does not state something, the cell says so rather than guessing.
| Product | Construction | Bed bug claim, as listed | Size and depth, as listed | Award |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| SafeRest Premium Zippered Mattress Encasement | Six-sided, zipped | Lab tested and certified bed bug proof, per the maker | Full Size; fits 6–9 in. deep, as listed | Best Overall |
| Utopia Bedding Zippered Mattress Encasement | Six-sided, zipped | Bed bug and dust mite proof, per the maker | US King in the title, Double in the size row | Best Value |
| SureGuard Premium Mattress Encasement | Six-sided, zipped | Bed bug proof with the matching box spring cover, per the maker | Full, 54" x 75"; fits 9–12 in. deep, as listed | Best for Comfort |
| Protect-A-Bed AllerZip Smooth Encasement | Six-sided per its description, fitted sheet per its bullets | not stated | Twin; 4–8 in. deep, as listed | Best Machine-Washable |
A cover protects the mattress only, and for an infestation the NHS advises contacting your local council or a pest control service (NHS).
Best Overall — SafeRest Premium Mattress Encasement
Encasement
SafeRest Premium Zippered Mattress Encasement
Best Overall
- The maker states it is independently lab tested and certified bed bug entry, escape and bite proof
- Six-sided cover with a micro-zipper the maker says bed bugs cannot pass through
- A velcro flap over the zipper end, described by the maker as preventing accidental openings
- Cotton terry surface over a membrane backing, per the listing
- Listed in US sizing: Full Size, fits 6 to 9 inches deep
As an Amazon Associate, PestPro Index earns from qualifying purchases.
If the bed bug claim is what you are buying for, this carries the strongest of the four: the maker says it is independently lab tested and certified bed bug entry, escape and bite proof. The micro-zipper is covered by a velcro flap at the end, which the maker says stops it opening by accident, and you sleep on cotton terry over a membrane backing. It is listed in US sizing as Full, for a mattress 6 to 9 inches deep, so measure yours first.
Pros:
- Lab tested and certified bed bug proof, per the maker
- Six-sided cover with a micro-zipper
- Velcro flap over the zipper end
- Cotton terry surface
Best Value — Utopia Bedding Mattress Encasement
Encasement
Utopia Bedding Zippered Mattress Encasement
Best Value
- Six-sided cover with a wrap-around zipper, per the listing
- The maker states it is bed bug and dust mite proof
- Knitted polyester with a waterproof backing, machine washable and tumble dryable
- Its title says US King and its size row says Double — the listing disagrees with itself
- Its own bullet describes a 78 by 80 inch mattress up to 15 inches deep
As an Amazon Associate, PestPro Index earns from qualifying purchases.
For a cover you want to wash often, since it goes in the washing machine and the tumble dryer. It is six-sided, with a wrap-around zipper, knitted polyester on top and a waterproof backing, and the maker states it is bed bug and dust mite proof. Check the size with care: the title says US King, the size row says Double, and a bullet describes a 78 by 80 inch mattress up to 15 inches deep.
Pros:
- Six-sided with a wrap-around zipper
- Bed bug and dust mite proof, per the maker
- Machine washable and tumble dryable
- Waterproof backing
Best for Comfort — SureGuard Mattress Encasement
Encasement
SureGuard Premium Mattress Encasement
Best for Comfort
- Six-sided cover with what the maker calls a superfine zipper and a sealing system
- The maker states the bed bug seal requires its matching box spring cover as well
- Cotton terry surface, described by the maker as noiseless and moisture-wicking
- The maker states it is free from vinyl, PVC, phthalates and flame retardants
- Listed in US sizing: Full, 54 by 75 inches, fits 9 to 12 inches deep
As an Amazon Associate, PestPro Index earns from qualifying purchases.
The one to look at if comfort is what you are buying for. The surface is cotton terry, which the maker describes as noiseless and moisture-wicking, and the maker states it is free from vinyl, PVC, phthalates and flame retardants. It is listed as Full, 54 by 75 inches, for a mattress 9 to 12 inches deep. The maker says its bed bug seal needs the matching box spring cover as well, so plan on both.
Pros:
- Cotton terry surface, noiseless per the maker
- Free from vinyl, PVC, phthalates and flame retardants, per the maker
- Superfine zipper with a sealing system, per the maker
- Fits mattresses 9 to 12 inches deep, as listed
Best Machine-Washable — Protect-A-Bed AllerZip
Encasement
Protect-A-Bed AllerZip Smooth Encasement
Best Machine-Washable
- Its product description calls it a six-sided encasement with a three-sided zipper
- Its feature bullets call it fitted sheet style — the listing disagrees with itself
- Jersey knit polyester over the maker's membrane, machine washable
- The only listing of the four that makes no bed bug claim in its own text
- Listed in US sizing: Twin, 4 to 8 inches deep
As an Amazon Associate, PestPro Index earns from qualifying purchases.
For a smooth jersey knit surface you can machine wash. The polyester sits over the maker's membrane, and its product description calls it a six-sided encasement with a three-sided zipper. It is listed as Twin, for a mattress 4 to 8 inches deep. It makes no bed bug claim in its own text, so choose another if that claim matters to you.
Pros:
- Jersey knit polyester over a membrane
- Machine washable
- Six-sided with a three-sided zipper, per its description
Start with your situation
- You have an active infestation. Read what a cover does not do before you read the cards.
- You want the strongest claim on the listing. The SafeRest is the one that states lab certification.
- You are protecting a mattress rather than treating one. The Utopia is the plainest of the four.
- You mind what it feels like to sleep on. The SureGuard states a cotton terry surface and a materials exclusion list.
- Your skin is the reason you are here. What the NHS and UC IPM say, and then a pharmacist or a GP.
Warning
The NHS says it is very difficult to get rid of bedbugs yourself and that you should contact your local council or pest control service. A mattress cover is not a substitute for that, and nothing on this page treats a room.
What an Encasement Is For
The University of California’s Statewide IPM Program describes the product class, and it is the clearest statement of what these covers do: “Mattress encasements specifically designed to prevent bed bugs from establishing harborages on mattresses are commercially available and have been shown to be effective through laboratory research.” (UC IPM).
And the mechanism, in one sentence: “Bugs trapped inside encasements will eventually die due to starvation.” It gives no period for that, and neither does any of the four listings below, so no period appears on this page.
There is a second reason these exist. UC IPM: “Pesticides aren’t generally applied to mattresses or bedding because of potential risk to people.” A cover is the option for the one surface a spray is not meant to reach.
What the NHS and UC IPM Say About the Bites
The NHS describes the pest and its bites in one sentence, and this page adds nothing to it: “Bedbugs are small insects that often live on furniture or bedding. Their bites can be itchy but do not usually cause other health problems.” (NHS).
UC IPM says the same thing about disease, with one qualification: “Bed bugs aren’t known to spread diseases, but scratching bites can lead to infections.” (UC IPM).
That is the whole of it. A page selling mattress covers is not the place to work out what is on your skin, and there is no symptom list here to check yourself against. If the bites are the reason you are reading this, a pharmacist or a GP is where that question goes.
Where an Encasement Does Not Work
Everywhere that is not the mattress. The NHS: “Bedbugs can hide in many places, including on bed frames, mattresses, clothing, furniture, behind pictures and under loose wallpaper.” (NHS). A cover addresses exactly one item on that list.
As the whole of a treatment. UC IPM: “Insecticide applications alone won’t control bed bug infestations.” If that is true of the insecticides, it is true of a barrier that carries none.
Against a population you have not found. The NHS says it is “very difficult to get rid of bedbugs yourself because they can be hard to find and may be resistant to some insecticides.” Its instruction is: “If you think you have bedbugs, you should contact your local council or pest control service.”
Once it is opened. Every one of these four works by being closed and staying closed. An unzipped cover is a bedsheet.
What Decides the Choice
1. What the listing claims about bed bugs, and how strongly
Three of the four make a bed bug claim in their own text and one makes none at all. Of the three, one states independent lab testing and certification, one states bed bug and dust mite proof without naming a test, and one states the seal only in combination with the same maker’s box spring cover. Those are three different claims and the cards keep them apart.
2. Depth, which is the measurement that actually fails
6 to 9 inches, up to 15 inches, 9 to 12 inches, 4 to 8 inches. A cover that will not close over the mattress does not work at all, and this is the number to check before any other.
3. That all four are listed in US sizes
Full, US King, Full 54 by 75 inches, Twin. One of them gives a different size in its title than in its own size row. No conversion appears on this page, because a converted figure would be our arithmetic rather than the listing’s fact.
4. The surface you will actually sleep on
Two state cotton terry, one states knitted polyester, one states jersey knit polyester. One of the four also states what it is free from — vinyl, PVC, phthalates and flame retardants — which is the maker’s own claim about its own materials.
If a Cover Is Not the Answer
Heat and cold. The NHS names a 60C wash with at least 30 minutes in a hot tumble dryer, and two to three weeks in a freezer for what cannot be washed.
Monitors under the bed legs. UC IPM describes commercially available double-cupped monitors installed under bed legs as a temporary exclusion measure. Our insect monitors page covers that class.
Treating the room rather than the mattress. Our bed bug spray and bed bug treatments pages cover the insecticides, with the same NHS caveat attached to both.
The council or a professional. The NHS’s first instruction. Our bed bug guide sets out what that involves.
Using Them
- Measure the depth first. Every one of these four states a depth range, and it is the specification that decides whether the cover closes at all.
- Read the size in the listing, not the name. All four are given in US sizes and one contradicts itself.
- Launder the bedding before you fit it. The NHS’s 60C wash and hot tumble dry come first, or you seal a clean mattress under dirty sheets.
- Close it fully and leave it closed. The mechanism UC IPM describes is containment, and it stops the moment the zip opens.
- Treat the rest of the room separately. Frames, headboards, skirting and furniture are on the NHS’s own list of hiding places and none of them is covered by a mattress cover.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do bed bug mattress encasements actually work?
UC IPM says that mattress encasements specifically designed to prevent bed bugs from establishing harbourages on mattresses are commercially available and have been shown to be effective through laboratory research, and that bugs trapped inside encasements will eventually die due to starvation. That is the source's finding about the product class, quoted; it is not a claim by this page about any of the four covers below.
How long should I leave one on?
No source read for this page states a figure, and none of the four listings states one either. UC IPM says trapped bugs die of starvation without giving a period. A number we invented would look exactly like a number we had measured, so there is no number here.
What size do I need?
Measure the depth of your mattress and match it against the depth range in the listing. Note that all four covers here are listed in US sizes — Full, US King, Full 54 by 75 inches, and Twin — and one of them gives a different size in its title than in its size row. Read the listing's own measurements rather than assuming a UK equivalent.
Is an encasement enough on its own?
The NHS's position on the infestation is that it is very difficult to get rid of bedbugs yourself because they can be hard to find and may be resistant to some insecticides, and that you should contact your local council or pest control service. UC IPM adds that bed bugs hide in bed frames, headboards, baseboards and furniture as well as in mattresses. A mattress cover covers a mattress.
Why not just spray the mattress?
UC IPM says pesticides are not generally applied to mattresses or bedding because of potential risk to people, and that insecticide applications alone will not control bed bug infestations. An encasement is the option that puts a barrier where a pesticide is not meant to go.
Are the bites dangerous?
The NHS says bedbug bites can be itchy but do not usually cause other health problems, and UC IPM says bed bugs are not known to spread diseases although scratching bites can lead to infections. Anything about your own skin is a question for a pharmacist or a GP, and the NHS page on bedbugs is where to read its own advice on that.